It appears obvious to most of us (experientially) that every event is preceded by a causal event, at least going back as far as the beginning of the universe. This is referred to as the deterministic view. To get around the creation event problem, we first created gods, then God, then an infinite inanimate forever universe. All would exist without a cause (Aristotle’s “unmoved mover” or first cause). While the causality (deterministic) theory makes obvious sense, it has problems, initially with free will and now with quantum mechanics. The deterministic view posits that with absolute knowledge regarding current state and the causes of events (including the laws of nature) we should be able to predict future states. Absolute knowledge regarding anything has so far proven to be impossible. However, if we all can agree that every event is caused by prior events, how can free will be a thing? Well, it seems that we can hold two opposing truths simultaneously. Possibly, somehow, we do not hold our decisions and the resultant action events to be 100% caused by prior events. Quantum mechanics also throws doubt on a causality chain view. Particles (waves?) appear to have multiple minds of their own making them unpredictable, unlocatable, and undefinable (wave or particle) thus producing randomness and probability in contradiction to determinism. Can you imagine the upheaval regarding morality and justice if it is determined with absolute certainty that free will does not exist? And, what if we went the other direction and determined that all events are random and unpredictable?
No comments:
Post a Comment